• Home
  • Local
  • State
  • National
  • International
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Obituaries
  • Crime
Dr. Oz and Governor Morrisey Announce More Than $3.4 Million for West Virginia Rural Health Care
Gov. Morrisey Announces West Virginia Bid to Host United States Space Academy
Gov. Morrisey Announces $9 Million to Expand College and Career Opportunities
  • Home
  • Local
  • State
  • National
  • International
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Obituaries
  • Crime

Federal Judge Rejects Supreme Court Candidate’s Challenge to Campaign Speech Limits

07 Apr 2026
WV Statewire
Off
By WV StatewireWV STATEWIRE
PUBLISHED: April 7, 2026

CHARLESTON — A federal judge has rejected a lawsuit filed by West Virginia Supreme Court candidate Martin “Red Hat” Sheehan, who argued that state rules governing judicial campaigns improperly restrict what candidates may say during an election.

Sheehan, a Wheeling attorney seeking one of two Supreme Court seats on the May 12 ballot, sued the West Virginia Judicial Investigation Commission on March 9 in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia.

The lawsuit challenged two provisions of the West Virginia Code of Judicial Conduct that apply to judges and judicial candidates. One bars candidates from making statements that could affect the outcome or fairness of a pending or impending case. The other prohibits candidates from making promises or commitments about issues likely to come before the court if those statements would undermine the impartial performance of judicial duties.

Federal Judge Rejects Supreme Court Candidate’s Challenge to Campaign Speech Limits

Sheehan argued the restrictions violate the First Amendment by limiting his ability to discuss legal issues with voters during the statewide campaign. He sought a temporary restraining order and other relief to block enforcement of the rules before the election.

Sheehan previously ran for the state’s high court in 2018 under the nickname “Red Shoes,” a reference to the red shoes he wore in court. He is listed on this year’s ballot as Martin “Red Hat” Sheehan.

Attorneys for the Judicial Investigation Commission argued that Sheehan had not been investigated or threatened with discipline and had not sought an advisory opinion from the commission before filing suit.

According to court filings, the commission maintained that it had taken no action against Sheehan and had not communicated with him before the lawsuit was filed.

The commission also argued that the campaign rules are narrowly written to preserve public confidence in an impartial judiciary.

U.S. District Judge Thomas Johnston ruled this week in favor of the commission, denying Sheehan’s request for a temporary restraining order, as well as his request for preliminary and permanent injunctions.

In his order, Johnston noted that Sheehan’s original court filings did not specify any particular statements he wished to make that would violate the code. The judge wrote that Sheehan first identified his desire to make such statements during a March 25 hearing in Charleston.

Johnston concluded that the state’s judicial campaign rules prohibit only a limited category of speech, including promises to decide future cases a certain way. He wrote that the rules still allow candidates to discuss legal and political issues and express their personal views, provided they do not compromise the appearance of judicial impartiality.

Five candidates are running for the unexpired Supreme Court term ending in 2032. Two seats on the state Supreme Court will appear on West Virginia ballots in the May 12 election.

WV Statewire
About the Author

Elkins Mail

Don't Miss
▸5.5% of West Virginia Voters Cast Ballots During First Four Days of Early Voting
5.5% of West Virginia Voters Cast Ballots During First Four Days of Early Voting
▸Dr. Oz and Governor Morrisey Announce More Than $3.4 Million for West Virginia Rural Health Care
Dr. Oz and Governor Morrisey Announce More Than .4 Million for West Virginia Rural Health Care
▸Gov. Morrisey Announces West Virginia Bid to Host United States Space Academy
Gov. Morrisey Announces West Virginia Bid to Host United States Space Academy
▸Gov. Morrisey Announces $9 Million to Expand College and Career Opportunities
Gov. Morrisey Announces  Million to Expand College and Career Opportunities
▸Governor Morrisey Offers Condolences Following the Passing of Ike Morris
Governor Morrisey Offers Condolences Following the Passing of Ike Morris

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • July 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • March 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • December 2025
  • November 2025
  • April 2025
  • January 2025
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • May 2012

Categories

  • Crime
  • Education
  • fashion
  • homepage
  • International
  • lifestyle
  • Local
  • misc
  • music
  • National
  • Obituaries
  • Politics
  • State
| The Elkins Mail © 2026. All rights reserved.